Optical Brighteners (often referred to as OBs, or Fluorescent
Whitening Agents - FWAs) are chemicals used in many contexts - for
example, they are put into detergents to achieve brighter whites and
stronger colours. Toothpaste is another common place they are found.
OBs
convert light through fluorescence, right at the far blue edge of the
visible spectrum (i.e. UV light) into visible light, thus making whites
appear cooler and brighter, and colours more saturated. This is done
for marketing reasons (i.e. look at our lovely bright whites) and also
to allow the manufacturer some tolerance in the paper making process
(e.g. if the paper base of a particular batch is a little more yellow
than spec, OBs can be used to cheaply bring the paper to a consistent
state).
The jury is still out for many people on whether OBs
are of real practical significance when considering the longevity of a
print. Some people believe OBs will simply fade away over time, leaving
the paper no warmer than it would have been anyway, and no warmer than
papers originally sold without them. Others believe the chemicals are
likely to have an effect on the long term survival of a paper (either
causing greater degradation over time, or leaving the paper more yellow
than it would have been were the OBs never present), and thus should be
avoided at all costs. Some people just don't like warmer papers and so
are willing to accept OBs no matter what the cost!
The
reality is that many prints made by great printers of days past, people
like Ansel Adams, were made on papers with OBs in them. Undoubtedly
they have a different visual appearance today to prints made on papers
that never had OBs in them, but it turns out that many of these prints
are still the preferred prints today! The character they have taken on
(through the OBs fading) is actually still appreciated! Thus, as usual,
the answer is not simple.
However, in terms of colour
management, OBs are a definite problem. Firstly, then tend to promote
metamerism, making colour casts on black and white prints under
different light sources much worse, and they also mean that what you
print now will not be what is on the page in a few years (as OBs fade
much more quickly than paper coatings without them)...thus all your
good work in colour management is negated after just a few years if you
use papers with OBs in them. It may be the fading is very minor, so
this may not be a real practical problem, of course, but some very
bright white papers have a LOT of OBs in them (e.g. a lot of the Epson
papers) so these should definitely be avoided.
If in doubt,
and particularly in the gallery market, it is probably best to avoid
them, or at least papers that have lots of them in them. Papers like Portfolio Rag, Silver Rag, and most of the Canson papers have only minimal amounts at most, or generally none at all, and are often still really quite a bright white.